Cornish Social & Economic Research Group

» What CoSERG Thinks


_______________________________________________
House prices are being hit by pessimism for second homes, say estate agents,
thisiscornwall.com, 11 August 2010

 


Slate advertising plaque on holiday home wall, St Ives cottage ( © CoSERG )

Image above: Slate advertising plaque on holiday home wall, St Ives cottage. ( © CoSERG )

Property professionals have blamed the slowdown of the second home market for growing pessimism in the region's housing market. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (Rics) said nationally eight per cent more of its members reported a fall than a rise in property prices in July. This is the first time the survey has recorded a fall in house prices since July 2009.

For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Piece by piece: Join the fight to halt the sprawl of development into our green spaces,
Juliette Jowit The Guardian, 6 August 2010

Thousands of wildlife habitats, including refuges for some of the country's rarest species and sites recognised worldwide for their importance to nature are under threat from development every year. The scale of the problem - from small garden-grabs to the construction of major housing estates, ports and roads - is revealed as the Guardian today launches a project called Piece by piece, to expose the creeping threat to Britain's natural world.

Jonathon Porritt, one of the UK's most influential environmental experts, said Piece by piece, a dedicated website that will collect evidence of developments and challenges to these , was "desperately" needed.

"If it's been badly needed over the last few years, I think that need is likely to become absolutely desperate over the next few years," said Porritt, former head of both Friends of the Earth and the government's Sustainable Development Commission.

For more...www.guardian.co.uk/environment

Image above: Boiler Works Road fields, Camborne - proposed 'green field' land for housing development. (© CoSERG )

_______________________________________________
The Right to Move: Tories plan to finish the job begun by Right to Buy,
Cornish Zetetics , 5 August 2010

In the 1980s Thatcher's Right to Buy devastated council housing in Cornwall. With house prices soaring out of reach of Cornish wages, decimating the number of council houses produced a housing crisis that we're still grappling with a generation later. In coastal villages in particular it also dealt a serious blow to local communities, transferring housing from indigenous families to the new Cornish and to second home owners.

For more...http://cornishzetetics.blogspot

_______________________________________________
Morrisons store has £500,000 for town to spend on community improvements,
thisiscornwall, 04 August 2010

Wadebridge could be given a £500,000 cash boost for town and community improvements. The rumoured half a million pound sum would come from Morrisons, one of three supermarket giants trying to build in the town. The money would be made available through a 106 planning agreement providing consent for a new store is granted. The company has already approached Wadebridge Chamber of Commerce and asked for a wish list of community projects it could help with.

Comment
At first the idea of a half million pounds for community benefit sounds desirable. Doubtless the issue of where to turn for funds when public spending is being cut will be raised as a reason for supporting the proposal. But there are some important issues here. In effect the planning gain concept introduced under a past Conservative government can be seen as a bribe to the local community. Supermarket chains will compete to gain support for developments, not on planning merits but on which one provides the best inducements.

A vital reform of the planning system is required here so that proposals are considered on their merits - what would be the impact of the proposal on the existing retail sector? What would be the impact on traffic generation? Is the land in question appropriate for development?

Funding for worthwhile projects should come out of taxation and supermarkets should be charged for the costs they impose on the community.

For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Trelawney Alliance announce intention ot fight the proposed Treswithian Intersection,
Trelawney Alliance, 1 August 2010

Trelawney Alliance has announced their intention of fighting the proposed Treswithian Intersection and plan to hold a public meeting later this month. They feel that it is vital that local people should be made aware of what is proposed for their area.

Alliance chairman Jean Charman stated. ‘The sole purpose of this intersection is to facilitate the proposed building of some 2,000 new homes in the Treswithian, Penponds. Boundervean Lane and Park Holly areas. It will also lead to the demolition of Blaythorne, the former Holmans Sports Club. Cornwall council Officers have already stated that these houses are for 82% inward migration, how can this area cope with a possible extra 4,500 cars?

Press release... Trelawney Alliance

_______________________________________________
Cornish resistance against bid to unite economy in 'Devonwall' partnership,
thisiscornwall, 29 July 2010

Plans to create a peninsula-wide body to boost the economic prospects of the Westcountry have been virtually killed off by resistance in Cornwall. The Western Morning News understands a statement is soon expected on the economic relationship between Devon and Cornwall as the deadline nears for alternative plans to the sprawling South West Regional Development Agency (RDA), which is soon to be abolished. But a formal "Devonwall" partnership, championed so the region can punch its weight when bidding for Whitehall funding, has been largely rejected in Cornwall.

Details of Cornwall Council's intentions have emerged after a motion in support of the formation of a local enterprise partnership (LEP) representing the county was unanimously passed by councillors. Sandra Rothwell, head of economic development of Cornwall Council, who is assembling the local authority's bid, indicated that a "bespoke" body for Cornwall, and possibly the Isles of Scilly, was the favoured option.

Councils in Devon had been working up plans to form a "peninsula-based" Devon and Cornwall LEP, and last night expressed disappointment that Cornwall appeared to be going alone.

Comment
Formation of a Cornwall LEP is to be welcomed, it accords with the aspirations for a Cornish Assembly and retains Cornwall's integrity. Supporters of 'Devonwall' seem to have forgotten that it was the abolition of 'Devonwall' that ensured Cornwall was eligible for European funding. As for the private sector calling the shots, a partnership is a partnership and where public funds are involved such a body should be accountable to elected representatives in Cornwall.

For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Figures show average house prices in Westcountry creeping towards £200,000,
thisiscornwall, 29 July 2010

Average house prices in Devon are on the verge of passing the £200,000-mark after the latest figures showed homes in the county increased nearly 10 per cent in the last year. The latest information released by the Land Registry show the average cost of a home in Devon now stands at £197,341, while the figure for Cornwall is £190,265. According to the House Prices Index, released on the 20th working day of every month, house prices in Devon are up 9.1 per cent on the same time last year. In Cornwall, buyers in June this year are paying an average of 7.8 per cent more than they would have 12 months earlier. That figure is below the national average increase of 8.4 per cent.

Image left: Carbis Bay 2 bedroom housing development, starting price £230,000. ( ©CoSERG August 2010 )

Comment
With house prices up there will be increasing concern over housing affordability in Cornwall. There are also questions as to why house prices are rising after a severe recession. Is it lack of supply, excess demand? What are the dynamics of the second home and investment markets?

[We apologise to readers who might point out that technically neither Devon or Cornwall are in the Westcountry!].

For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Cornwall Council cuts will cost 2,000 jobs as £110m has to be saved in four years,
This is Cornwall, 28 July 2010

About 2,000 council jobs in Cornwall are to be axed in a bid to save £110 million over the next four years in local government spending. The shock announcement came yesterday as Cornwall Council chiefs revealed they would be setting their own emergency budget for next year in November. The move comes ahead of the outcome of the Government's spending review.

Comment
The fall-out from the new Governments policies of cutting public expenditure continues apace. Any job cuts whether during the recession or in the recovery phase are harmful, to the individuals concerned, the community and the wider economy. Government policy ignores these issues oblivious of the impact.

For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
New turbines are to repower the efficiency of pioneering wind farm, doubling output,
This is Cornwall, 27 July 2010

Britain's first commercial wind farm is gearing up to start the process of repowering next month. Built in 1991, the Delabole Wind Farm is replacing the ten original turbines with four larger and more powerful ones which will more than double the current output. The new turbines are almost twice the height of the old ones. They will measure 64 metres to the hub and 99.5 metres to the tip compared to the 32-metre hub height and 50-metre tip height of the old turbines. The new turbines harness the wind far more efficiently. The project is costing Good Energy £12m and the turbines represent the second generation of onshore wind power in the UK.

Comment
No doubt questions were raised about the impact on the landscape, but there are far worse developments which impact on the landscape. Investing in renewables has advantages for the Cornish economy and for reducing carbon output. A move towards greater community ownership might also assist in regenerating the economy and ensuring money is retained within the Cornish economy.

More here... www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Planning row puts ferry link to Isles of Scilly earmarked funding funding in danger,
This is Cornwall, 26 July 2010

Transport Secretary, Philip Hammond, has warned funding for the "lifeline" link between the Isles of Scilly and the mainland is at risk until the Battle of Battery Rocks is resolved, the 'Western Morning News' can reveal. Mr Hammond acknowledged that there is a "special case" to be made for protecting around £24 million of Department for Transport(DfT) cash earmarked for providing a ferry link between the Scillies and Cornwall.

Comment
The Battery Rocks saga has revealed weaknesses in the planning system, relating to the consultation process, decision making and funding. Fundamental questions about the stage at which consultation should proceed – before rather than after consultants have looked at proposals; who should decide – the local community or a Cornish strategic body?; and, would it not be better if Cornwall had a pot of funds to dispense rather than have to ask for funding?
More...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Planning precedent says 'NO' to Steeple Fields development,
St Ives Times and Echo, 23 July 2010

Emotions on both sides of the debate were running high when protesters at a meeting arranged by St Ives Trust clashed with Cornwall Care Ltd, over their proposed development of a care home and retirement complex on Steeple Fields.

Around 250 people including both of the town's Cornwall Councillors, St Ives Town Councillors and a Cornwall Council planning officer were in attendance. None of the councillors or the planning officer took part in the discussions having made it clear that they were attending to listen and observe. However the Council's planning officer stated that due to some technicalities the submitted controversial plans had not yet been registered.

For the Save the Steeple Fields Campaign, Rita Lait delivered an impassioned plea for the environmental and heritage value of the site. Among the many arguments she made to explain why the development was inappropriate on the site, was that the intrusion of the complex into the broad 'green corridor' below Knill's Steeple is of particular significance.

News source (No online news)... St Ives Times & Echo

Further news...
Public meeting told scheme is not 'done deal',
South West Business, 22 July 2010

The project manager for Cornwall Care denied that getting permission for its Steeple Fields development is a done deal at a public meeting on Tuesday. A divided crowd packed the Bedford Road Methodist Church to hear presentations from the county's biggest care provider and from Rita Lait, spokesperson for Save Steeple Fields.

The opposition raised the prospect of the scheme causing traffic chaos both during and after the works, of it ruining a nature corridor, of kicking off a development rush in the area and of wrecking a piece of St Ives' heritage for future generations. Towards the end of the meeting a voice from the crowd claimed there would be no trouble with getting the planning application approved as it was already a "done deal." Greg Oldrieve, project manager, knocked back those claims, saying: "I absolutely refute this supposition." Having investigated 12 other sites he said they had done their research but would consider alternative suggestions as long as they were "available, suitable and viable".

News source...www.southwestbusiness.co.uk/cornwall

_______________________________________________
U-Turn On Housing,
theyworkforyou.com, 22 July 2010

George Eustice (Camborne and Redruth, Conservative)
"One of the projects currently under review in my area is the east-west link road in Camborne and Redruth, which is a crucial element of a broader regeneration project, led by the private sector, that would create 6,000 new jobs. Does the Secretary of State agree that when it comes to prioritising transport projects after the comprehensive spending review, one of the key criteria to apply will be the impact on enterprise and jobs?"

Norman Baker (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State (Regional and Local Transport), Transport; Lewes, Liberal Democrat). "I fully understand the importance attached to that scheme in my hon. Friend's constituency. I can confirm to him that the impact on the economy and job creation will be a factor taken into account in deciding whether to proceed with the scheme, along with the public finances and the opportunity to reduce carbon emissions".

Comment
Pre his elevation to the Commons, Mr Eustace was against the 'bonkers' housing figures for the Camborne-Redruth area. The east west highway is part and parcel of the plans for the extra houses and associated jobs. At odds with previous views?
More here...www.theyworkforyou.com

Ref: Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 22 July 2010, c552)

_______________________________________________
Industry supremo backs campaigners' fight for look of countryside,,
ThisisCornwall,17 July 2010

Leading businessman Sir John Banham has joined forces with countryside campaigners to challenge developments alleged to be inappropriate. The former head of the Confederation of British Industry, who was raised and lives in Cornwall, has given the intellectual property rights associated with a High Court victory to the Campaign for the Protection of Rural England (CPRE).

Last year, plans to build a house and barn in a designated Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty in the village of Treen, West Cornwall, were overturned following his crusade. As well as allowing CPRE members to use his legal arguments, which cost in the region of £100,000, Sir John has agreed to become patron of the Cornish branch of the campaign organisation.

Green fields at Tuckingmill planned for development (CoSERG July 2010)

Image above: Green area at Tuckingmill planned for development ( CoSERG July 2010 ).

 

Comment
The Cornish countryside is indeed under threat. Yet the threat is not so much around the coastline or in the 'nice' areas but in and adjacent to existing urban areas. Some countryside campaigners take a narrow view of which developments are inappropriate. Windfarms and agricultural barns in AONBs are deemed bad but do they feel the same about developments that impact upon communities in urban areas?
For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Controversial Cornish pier has heritage status upgraded,
This is Cornwall, 29 June 2010

The historical status of a Cornish pier at the centre of a bitter planning row has been upgraded by the Government to make it one of the country’s most important harbours. Building watchdog English Heritage advised the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Eric Pickles to elevate the South Pier in Penzance from Grade a II to Grade II* listing. A report by English Heritage said the South Pier is “amongst the best preserved of early Cornish harbours” and that “compared with the majority of highly-graded harbours, the historical significance of Penzance is particularly high”. The move has invigorated campaigners opposed to the plans drawn up by the Route Partnership, which is made up of Cornwall Council, the Council of the Isles of Scilly and the Duchy of Cornwall. For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Recycling initiatives boost levels and earn council national award,
This is Cornwall, 29 June 2010

A recycling campaign by Cornwall Council has boosted recycling levels and gained it a national award. The council's innovative work in engaging the public was recognised at the national Plant and Waste Recycling Awards at the Imperial Hotel in Torquay. The council's waste awareness team carried out a three-month intensive campaign to raise recycling levels in the St Austell and St Blazey area, which featured a revolutionary Big Green Ticket scheme whereby residents could win shopping vouchers.

Julian German, Cornwall Council cabinet member for waste management, said: "We're thrilled to have run such a successful campaign and to win national recognition. It is a fantastic initiative because it takes all of the good work that we have developed over the last few years across Cornwall and focuses it on a specific area.

Comment
Reduce, reuse, recycle - all necessary if we are to waste less. Hopefuly more people in Cornwall will recycle more now.
For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Impressive change from poor man to powerhouse,
This is Cornwall, 25 June 2010

It doesn't seem so long ago that Cornwall's sprawling urban Camborne Pool Redruth corridor was struggling to keep up in a county that seemed to be leaving it behind. A legacy of long since shut down heavy industry, poor transport links and decaying housing stock made it the butt of many a joke. The fact that the ordinary, down-to-earth towns are sandwiched between arty St Ives to the north and thriving Falmouth to the south made the distinction that much greater. But the CPR area is limping no more and in an impressively short period of time has transformed from poor man to powerhouse.

Comment
Yes the area is unrecognisable - a dual carriageway from East Hill to the A30, a huge new crossroads at East Hill - and more roads to come! Apart from the visual impact, not exactly a move towards reducing traffic and pollution? And if all the other developments proposed go ahead, the area will be even more unrecognisable - fewer green areas, more traffic, loss of community. Unrecognizable, undesirable and unsustainable. Powerhouse? More development does not equal becoming a powerhouse.
For More...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk

_______________________________________________
Recession hits SW population growth,
By Donald Barr, Economics and Evidence Manager, SW Regional Development Agency,24 June 2010

Figures published today by the Office for National Statistics, estimate that the resident population in the South West region grew by 0.4% in the year to mid-2009, barely half of the pre-recession rate and well below the UK average.

According to these estimates, since the start of the recession annual net international migration has dropped below zero - more are leaving than arriving - and internal migration has fallen by a third from 29,000 a year to 19,000. These are understandable effects of the recession as the UK generally has become a less attractive destination for European workers, and conditions in the housing and investment markets have created very difficult conditions for many who would otherwise have been planning to retire to the region.

Comment
Does population growth actually help economic growth? Does 'wealth' from retirees assist the economy or push up house prices?

In terms of sustainability population growth cannot continue. Simply arguing that population growth helps the economy fails to take account of the negative impacts.

For more...www.southwestrda.org.uk/news_and_events

_______________________________________________
Plans to use the planet's heat for energy move a step closer,
This is Cornwall, 24 June 2010

Plans to create the country's first geothermal power station, in the heart of the Cornish countryside, could move a step closer today if councillors agree to visit the proposed development site. Renewable power company Geothermal Engineering Ltd wants to tap into the "hot rocks" technology as part of a £40 million plan for United Downs at St Day. If given the go-ahead, the project would draw on Cornwall's mining heritage by drilling huge holes into the ground as part of the renewable energy process. Residents are concerned about noise levels during the drilling process, as well as possible impacts on wildlife. But the energy company recently held a site meeting to demonstrate noise levels, which it says will be no louder than conversational speech.

Comment
An opportunity to exploit Cornwall's resources? If the scheme can produce energy for the area then it should assist in reducing our dependence on fossil fuels.
For more...www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Moves to dismantle regional regime announced,
Planning Portal, Communities and Local Government, 24 June 2010

Communities secretary Eric Pickles has begun to dismantle the funding and powers of regional local authority leaders' boards, which took over most of the functions and staff of the old regional assemblies. The boards are set to become redundant as the current regime of regional strategies is abolished. The dismantling of these boards will see local authorities put back in control of delivering services and provision for their area. Pickles said: "This is another step in wresting control from the bureaucrats, stopping the top-down diktats and axing unelected, ineffective quangos.”
More here...www.planningportal.gov.uk

_______________________________________________
Former MP will lead flagship eco-town project in clay country,
This is Cornwall, 7 June 2010

Matthew Taylor, the former Liberal Democrat MP for Truro and St Austell, is to be the independent chairman of the board co-ordinating Cornwall's flagship eco-town project. The politician, who stood down ahead of last month's General Election, will be responsible for helping to bring together developers, planners, funding bodies and environmental groups to ensure the multi-million project across six former clay mines in St Austell is a success. Mr Taylor said: "High quality affordable homes, sustainable new employment, and the facilities needed for strong communities and neighbourhoods - this is the opportunity. My job will be to help this happen, working with the community as well as Government agencies to make sure we get it right. "Having lived in the clay community for 23 years, I share the hopes, and know the challenges we face. Now it is time to deliver."

Comment
What else is there to add? Is an ecotown simply more unsustainable development but badged as being eco-friendly?
For More....www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/news

_______________________________________________
Aerial survey shows Cornwall's landscape is changing,
BBC News, 5 June 2010

Researchers studied aerial photographs of the county taken between 1995 and 2005 to record the changes. The photographs showed that farmland and wetlands had been replaced with modern developments. Dave Lewis from Cornwall Council, which organised the study, said: "It's predicted we might lose 40% of our wildlife species over 50 years." Mr Lewis added: "It's very difficult to imagine what Cornwall would be like if we lost half our wildlife." Researchers at Cornwall Wildlife Trust studied the photographs and recorded the data. Enclosed farmland has also decreased with about 4,700 acre acres lost to developments. Mary Combe from the Farming and Wildlife Advisory Group said: "The worrying thing about it is it's the edge of farmland people are willing to sell, when that's the most important part for wildlife because of the hedges and scrub."

Comment
Unsurprising news in many ways. Cornwall has seen and continues to see unsustainable levels of development - roads, dwellings and associated developments. Unless the projected levels of population growth are halted and to some extent reversed there will be less land available for wildlife and less wildlife. At the same time much of the existing landscape is mismanaged. Farmers and other landowners continue to destroy the environment through unnecessary trimming. Many gardeners remove any trace of wild plants and in the process the animals that feed on them, from their gardens, leaving instead the ubiquitous desert of the lawn. There is a general consensus that keeping the place 'tidy' is a good thing, hence the mown verges near roads and removal of annoying areas of 'wildness'. Until society changes its attitude to the environment and recognises limits to growth, little will change.
More...BBC News

 

_______________________________________________
CLICK HERE FOR OLDER NEWS _______________________________________________
Back to top of page